• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Anchored in Christ

KevinHalloran.net

  • Home
  • About Me
    • Contact
  • Popular Posts
  • Speaking
  • Resources
    • Recommended Resources
    • The Gospel
    • Free Prayer Tools
    • 100+ Book Recommendations for Christians
    • 100+ of the Best Christian Biographies
    • 250+ Free Online Seminary Classes, Courses, Programs, and Book Recommendations
    • Accessible Theology Book Series
  • When Prayer Is a Struggle
  • Videos
  • Español

Kevin / October 19, 2013

Quotes from J.I. Packer on the Charismatic Movement

In his book Keep In Step With the Spirit, theologian J.I. Packer wrote a helpful theological work on the person and work of the Holy Spirit and shared in a couple of chapters his thoughts on the charismatic movement taking place in much of the world today.

My goals for sharing this is not to choose sides or argue for a middle ground in the recently renewed interest in debating cessationalism and the charismatic faith (reignited by the StrangeFire conference and book by John MacArthur) but rather to share helpful truths for both sides to ponder.

I hope the information presented here will help both sides avoid misunderstandings that lead to straw men argumentation, widening the chasm between the differing sides within the body of Christ that Christ so desperately wanted to be unified (John 17:23).

Below are some quotations from the chapters called “The Charismatic Life” and “Interpreting the Charismatic Life” from Packer’s book:

A different hermeneutical approach for Charismatics:

Protestant charismatics under Pentecostal influence tend to read all the details of New Testament charismatic experience as paradigms and, in effect, promises of what God will do for all who ask, while thoughtful Catholics plus the Protestant charismatic minority of whom I spoke above read them rather as demonstrating what God can do as spiritual need requires. (183)

Testing the charismatic movement with basic biblical tests:

…Scripture yields other principles for judging whether movements are God inspired or not—principles about God’s work, will, and ways that the Apostles themselves apply in letters like Galatians, Colossians, 2 Peter, and 1 John to various supposedly superficial versions of the faith. Two basic tests emerge: one credal and one moral:

The creedal test may be formulated from two passages, 1 John 4:2-3 and 1 Corinthians 12:3. The first passage says that any spirit—that is, evidently, anyone claiming to be Spirit inspired—who fails to confess the Incarnation is not of God. The thrust of this fully appears only as we recall that for John the incarnation of God’s Son led on to his sacrificial death for our sins (1:1-2:2, 3:16; 4:8-10), so that denying the former involved denying the latter, too. The second passage affirms that the Spirit of God leads no one to say “cursed [anathema] be Jesus,” but leads men rather to call him Lord (kyrios), which otherwise they could never sincerely do (see 1 Corinthians 2:14). Both passages illustrate the truth that is central to this present book, namely that the Spirit’s constant task is to make men discern and acknowledge the glory of Jesus Christ. So the credal test, for charismatics as for all other professed Christians, is the degree of honor paid by confession, attitude, and action to the Son whom God the Father has made Lord.

The moral test is given by statements such as those of John, that he who truly knows and loves God will show it by keeping his commandments, avoiding all sin and loving his brethren in Christ (see 1 John 2:4; 3:9, 10, 17, 24; 4:7-13, 20-21; 5:1-3).

When we apply these tests to the charismatic movement, it becomes plain at once that God is in it. For whatever threats and perhaps instances of occult and counterfeit spirituality we may think we detect round its periphery (and what movement of revival has ever lacked these things round its periphery?), its main effect everywhere is to promote robust Trinitarian faith, personal fellowship with the divine Saviour and Lord whom we meet in the New Testament, repentance, obedience, and love to fellow Christians, expressed in ministry of all sorts towards them—plus a zeal for evangelistic outreach that puts the staider sort of churchmen to shame. (184-185)

Positive and Negative Aspects of the Movement:

Positive Aspects (185-191):

  • Christ Centeredness,
  • Spirit-Empowered Living,
  • Emotion finding expression,
  • Prayerfulness,
  • Joyfulness,
  • Every-heart involvement in the worship of God,
  • Every-member ministry in the body of Christ,
  • Missionary zeal,
  • Small-group ministry,
  • Attitude toward church structures,
  • Communal living, and
  • Generous giving

Negative Aspects (191-197):

  • Elitism,
  • Sectarianism,
  • Emotionalism,
  • Anti-intellectualism,
  • Illuminism,
  • “Charismania,”
  • “Super-supernaturalism” (thinking God only is working through wondrous or miraculous works and not by natural means),
  • Eudaemonism (belief that God means us to spend our time in this fallen world feeling well and in a state of euphoria),
  • Demon obsession,
  • Conformism (being motivated more by peer pressure to practice certain spiritual gifts or worship a certain way)

Packer provides added clarity on his view of differences between charismatics and non-charismatics closing his chapter called “The Charismatic Life:”

…I suggest that, in reality, charismatic and non-charismatic spiritualties differ more in vocabulary, self-image, groups associated with, and books and journals read, than in the actual ingredients of their communion with the Father and the Son through the Spirit. Charismatic experience is less distinctive than is sometimes made out. (199)

Packer on building theology on experience:

The sign that an experience is a gift of God’s grace is that when it is tested by Scripture, it proves to have its heart an intensified awareness of some revealed truth concerning God and our relationship with him as creatures, sinners, beneficiaries, believers, adopted sons, pledged servants or whatever. We have measured charismatic experience by this criterion and not found it wanting. But when that experience is pointed to—and it often is—as evidence for beliefs that appear to be biblically mistaken, we are left with only two options: either to reject the experiences as delusive and possibly demonic in origin, after all, or to retheologize them in a way which shows that the truth which they actually evidence and confirm is something different from what the charismatics themselves suppose. (201)

Read more: J.I. Packer’s 9 Concluding Thoughts on the Charismatic Movement

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrint Friendly

Related Posts

  • J.I. Packer’s 9 Conclusions on the Charismatic MovementJ.I. Packer’s 9 Conclusions on the Charismatic Movement
  • 15 of the Best Christian Books on Grief, Death, and Suffering15 of the Best Christian Books on Grief, Death, and Suffering
  • 10 Actions Christ Promises to Reward10 Actions Christ Promises to Reward
  • Why Did Jesus Pray in Private So Often? (Thomas Brooks)Why Did Jesus Pray in Private So Often? (Thomas Brooks)
  • A List of Great Christian Videos Free on Amazon Prime VideoA List of Great Christian Videos Free on Amazon Prime Video

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

Filed Under: Bible & Theology, Quotes Tagged With: Charismatic Theology

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. J.I. Packer’s 9 Thoughts on the Charismatic Movement | Kevin Halloran | Christian Resources and Ideas to Inform and Transform says:
    October 19, 2013 at 12:58 pm

    […] Continued from previous post: J.I. Packer Quotes on the Charismatic Movement […]

Primary Sidebar

Let’s Connect

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Now Available in Paperback, Kindle, and Audiobook

Recent Posts

  • Recommended Links for September 2023
  • Ten Ideas for Cultivating Small Group Prayer
  • Recommended Links for August 2023
  • Praying Paul’s Prayer from Ephesians 1:15–23
  • Recommended Links for July 2023
  • A Biblical Tool for Cultivating Godly Emotions
  • Recommended Links for June 2023
  • 31 Ways God Can Use Your Suffering for Good
  • A Prayer to Not Waste Your Suffering
  • God’s Purpose for Your Suffering

Blog Sponsors

Blog Categories

Bible & Theology Books & Reviews Christian Living Culture Evangelism Humor Leadership Life Links Marriage & Relationships Ministry Missions Prayer Quotes Resources Social Media & Technology






Footer

About Me

I serve with Open the Bible. I wrote When Prayer Is a Struggle: A Practical Guide for Overcoming Obstacles in Prayer(P&R). And I'm glad you're here. Learn More about Me

Let’s Connect!

Follow me on Facebook

Follow me on Twitter

Follow me on Instagram

Subscribe to my channel on YouTube

Videos: When Prayer Is a Struggle

FTC Disclosure of Material Connection: I sometimes share affiliate links, meaning if you make a purchase through a link, I make a small commission at no extra cost to you to cover blogging expenses.

Copyright © 2023 · Digital Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.