• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Anchored in Christ

KevinHalloran.net

  • Home
  • About Me
    • Contact
  • Popular Posts
  • Speaking
  • Resources
    • The Gospel
    • Accessible Theology Book Series
    • 100+ Book Recommendations for Christians
    • 100+ of the Best Christian Biographies
    • 250+ Free Online Seminary Classes, Courses, Programs, and Book Recommendations
  • When Prayer Is a Struggle
  • Videos
  • Español

Kevin / June 21, 2016

The Truth Behind the Blind Men and the Elephant Analogy

The Blind Men and the Elephant Analogy is a common argument used by religious pluralists to illustrate their belief that all religions are essentially equal.

The-Blind-Men-and-the-Elephant-Analogy-Parable-Christian-ResponseThe basic argument goes like this:

  • There are several blind men who all encounter an elephant.
  • One of the blind men feels the trunk of the elephant, and thinks the elephant is like a snake.
  • The second blind man disagrees, because after feeling the side of the elephant, he believes the elephant to be more like an immovable wall.
  • The third finds the first two ridiculous, because after feeling the leg of the elephant, he thinks the elephant to be a tree.
  • And the fourth man disagrees as well, feeling the tail was more like a skinny broom than a snake, wall, or tree.

Therefore, none of the blind men are wrong per se, because they have different views and experiences of the same thing. The argument goes that religious people are just like the blind men feeling the elephant, just encountering the same truth in different ways.

On the surface, this can be a convincing argument and hard to defend—but it shouldn’t be, because it is built upon flawed logic.

What should the Christian response be to the Parable of the Blind Men and the Elephant?

In the video below, Matt Chandler offers a powerful rebuttal to this common parable.

“The only way the parable of the Blind Men and the Elephant makes any sense is if the narrator of the story sees the whole elephant.”

“The moment you claim ultimate reality is unknowable, you have just claimed the knowledge of what you said can’t be known! This is intellectually inconsistent.” Matt Chandler

Image Credit

A version of this post originally published on December 28, 2012. 

Print Friendly, PDF & EmailPrint Friendly

Related Posts

  • Praying to Make the Most of the Grieving ProcessPraying to Make the Most of the Grieving Process
  • Gospel Hope for Anxious HeartsGospel Hope for Anxious Hearts
  • A Prayer for ContentmentA Prayer for Contentment
  • 25 Bible Verses about Guidance / Finding God’s Will for Your Life25 Bible Verses about Guidance / Finding God’s Will for Your Life
  • 10 Reasons the Resurrection of Jesus Christ is Important10 Reasons the Resurrection of Jesus Christ is Important

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WhatsApp
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

Filed Under: Evangelism

Primary Sidebar

Let’s Connect

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Now Available in Paperback, Kindle, and Audiobook

Recent Posts

  • Pray This Simple Bible Verse for Your Kids
  • How to Prepare Yourself for the Lord’s Supper
  • My Social Media Guardrails
  • The Disciples Wouldn’t Have Died for a Lie
  • Spiritual Lessons from Baseball’s All-Time Greats
  • How to Focus in Prayer: 7 Tips
  • Praying the Lord’s Prayer for the Ukrainian Church
  • How to Pray the Prayers of the Apostle Paul [Video]
  • 10 Worship Songs for Celebrating Communion
  • A Brief Review of God, Technology, and the Christian Life by Tony Reinke

Blog Sponsors

Blog Categories

Bible & Theology Books & Reviews Christian Living Culture Evangelism Humor Leadership Life Links Marriage & Relationships Ministry Missions Prayer Quotes Resources Social Media & Technology Uncategorized






Footer

About Me

I serve with Open the Bible. I wrote When Prayer Is a Struggle: A Practical Guide for Overcoming Obstacles in Prayer (P&R). Learn more about the book.

Learn More

Let’s Connect!

Follow me on Facebook

Follow me on Twitter

Follow me on Instagram

Subscribe to me on YouTube

Videos: When Prayer Is a Struggle

FTC Disclosure of Material Connection: I sometimes share affiliate links, meaning if you make a purchase through a link, I make a small commission at no extra cost to you to cover blogging expenses.

Copyright © 2022 · Digital Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...
 

    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.